Systems and Means of Informatics
2022, Volume 32, Issue 3, pp 4-14
SOME METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES OF ASSESSING THE LEVEL OF TECHNOLOGICAL READINESS OF INFORMATION SYSTEMS PROJECTS
- A. A. Zatsarinny
- Yu. S. Ionenkov
Abstract
The article is devoted to the issues of assessing the level of technological readiness of information systems (IS) projects. General approaches to assessing the level of readiness of projects abroad and in Russia are presented. It is shown that at present, an approach using the methods of assessing technological/production/market readiness levels (TRL/MRL/CRL) based on a 9-level scale and allowing to assess the level of readiness of technology, production, and product readiness to enter the market is becoming increasingly developed. The advantages of these methods are considered. It is noted that in Russia, they are mainly used in corporate projects and are practically not used in the development of IS projects in the interests of public administration. Proposals are formulated to improve the methods of evaluating IS projects including a methodological approach to assessing the level of technological readiness of projects.
[+] References (10)
- Zatsarinnyy, A. A., and Yu. S. Ionenkov. 2020. Otsenka effektivnosti informatsionno- telekommunikatsionnykh sistem [Evaluation of the effectiveness of information and telecommunication systems]. Moscow: NIPKTs Voskhod-A. 120 p.
- Zatsarinny, A. A., Yu. S. Ionenkov, and A. P. Suchkov. 2021. Nekotorye voprosy otsenki kachestva informatsionnykh sistem [Some issues of information system quality assessment]. Sistemy i Sredstva Informatiki - Systems and Means of Informatics
31(4):4-17.
- Mankins, J. C. 1995. Technology readiness level. Advanced Concepts Office of Space Access and Technology NASA. Available at: https://aiaa.kavi.com/apps/group_ public/download.php/2212/TRLs_MankinsPaper_1995.pdf (accessed August 15, 2022).
- Manufacturing Readiness Level (MRL) Deskbook. Version 2.0. 2011. OSD Manufacturing Technology Program. Available at: https://www.dodmrl.com/MRL_ Deskbook_V2.pdf (accessed August 15, 2022).
- Metrika "Rynochnaya gotovnost' CRL" [The "Market readiness CRL" metric]. Available at: https://www.rosatom.ru/upload/iblock/fb2/fb23f5ee18bc97e7c0e2 f14df9146f6a.pdf (accessed August 15, 2022).
- GOST 56861-2016. 2017. Sistema upravleniya zhiznennym tsiklom. Razrabotka kontseptsii izdeliya i tekhnologiy. Obshchie polozheniya [Lifecycle management system. Product concept and technology development. General provisions]. Moscow: Standartinform Publs. 11 p.
- Urovni gotovnosti produkta/tekhnologii po osnovnym sostavlyayushchim proekta: Tekhnologicheskaya gotovnost', proizvodstvennaya gotovnost' i gotovnost' k vykhodu na rynok [Product/technology readiness levels for the main components of the project: Technology readiness level/manufacturing readiness level/commercialization readiness level]. Available at: http://ctt.volnc.ru/uploads/activity_files/2020/08/14251. pdf (accessed August 15, 2022).
- Petrov, A. N., A. V. Sartory, and A. V. Filimonov. 2016. Kompleksnaya otsenka sostoyaniya nauchno-tekhnicheskikh proektov cherez uroven' gotovnosti tekhnologiy [Comprehensive assessment of the status of scientific and technical projects using Technology Project Readiness Level]. Ekonomika nauki [Economics of Science] 2(4):244-260.
- Komarov, A. V., A. N. Petrov, and A. V. Sartory. 2018. Model' kompleksnoy otsenki tekhnologicheskoy gotovnosti innovatsionnykh nauchno-tekhnicheskikh proektov [The model of integrated assessment of technological readiness of innovative scientific and technological projects]. Ekonomika nauki [Economics of Science] 4(1):47-57.
- Metodicheskie rekomendatsii po sopostavleniyu urovnya tekhnologicheskogo razvitiya i znacheniy klyuchevykh pokazateley effektivnosti aktsionernykh obshchestv s gosudarstvennym uchastiem, gosudarstvennykh korporatsiy, gosudarstvennykh kompaniy i federal'nykh gosudarstvennykh unitarnykh predpriyatiy s urovnem razvitiya i pokazatelyami vedushchikh kompaniy-analogov: Prilozhenie No. 2 k protokolu No. 2 ot 19 sentyabrya 2017 g. zasedaniya Mezhvedomstvennoy rabochey gruppy po realizatsii prioritetov innovatsionnogo razvitiya prezidiuma Soveta pri Prezidente RF po modernizatsii i innovatsionnomu razvitiyu Rossii [Methodological recommendations for comparing the level of technological development and the values of key performance indicators of state-owned joint-stock companies, state corporations, state-owned com-panies, and federal state unitary enterprises with the level of development and indicators of leading analog companies: Appendix No. 2 to Protocol No. 2 dated September 19,
2017, of the Meeting of the Interdepartmental Working Group on the Implementation of Innovation Development Priorities of the Presidium of the Council under the President of the Russian Federation for Modernization and Innovative Development of Russia]. Available at: https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/file/535256 e8193016b438e70338a9a0d42d/metodic_ta_mrg.pdf (accessed August 15, 2022).
[+] About this article
Title
SOME METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES OF ASSESSING THE LEVEL OF TECHNOLOGICAL READINESS OF INFORMATION SYSTEMS PROJECTS
Journal
Systems and Means of Informatics
Volume 32, Issue 3, pp 4-14
Cover Date
2022-06-11
DOI
10.14357/08696527220301
Print ISSN
0869-6527
Publisher
Institute of Informatics Problems, Russian Academy of Sciences
Additional Links
Key words
project; information system; project readiness level; technological readiness; production readiness
Authors
A. A. Zatsarinny  and Yu. S. Ionenkov
Author Affiliations
Federal Research Center "Computer Science and Control", Russian Academy of Sciences, 44-2 Vavilov Str., Moscow 119333, Russian Federation
|